They copied a bag he cuts by hand. He is not retiring — he is being undersold out of a trade his family has been in since 1931, and there are 398 bags on the shelves that will not be replaced.
Summary: Gloversville, New York once produced the majority of leather gloves sold in the United States. Thirty tanneries operated in one valley; you can now count what is left on one hand. When the one Wade Merrick had bought from all his life shut its doors, he took the hides that were still on the floor rather than watch them go out as scrap. Third generation, fifty-one years at the bench, he spent two years cutting them into 398 keyboard bags . When the last of them is gone he closes the workshop for good — not because he wants to stop, but because hand-cutting leather in America stopped paying its own way. There is no second batch and there will not be another business. Both sizes have been set at $49 , down from $109.
He did not plan to buy them. He went down because he had bought leather from that building for most of his working life and it seemed wrong not to be there on the last day.
The hides were stacked by the loading door, chalk marks still on them. He asked what was happening to the rest. He was told: scrap.
What actually happened to this valley
If you have never heard of Gloversville, the name is the whole explanation. For roughly a century it made almost every leather glove worn in America. Thirty tanneries along one river, cutting rooms over the storefronts, whole families in the trade.
Wade’s grandfather cut his first pair here in 1931, his father after him. Wade started at twenty-two and has not stopped since.
Then, across about twenty years, it ended. Goods arrived from overseas that looked like leather, cost a third as much, and did not last. That last part turned out not to matter. Price became the only argument anyone was still making, and a valley full of people who knew how to do this lost it.
“People say it like a tragedy and I don’t think it was one, exactly,” Wade says. “Nobody came in here and took it. Everybody just quietly decided it wasn’t worth paying for. That’s a different thing, and it’s worse.”
He is not bitter about it, which unsettles people more than bitterness would.
He kept a small shop through all of it. Belts, straps, rebuilding old cases nobody else would take. That was the whole business, and it was never a large one.
And it did not stop twenty years ago. It is still happening, to him, now.
“I can cut one of these in about a day and a half. There is a bag on the internet this morning that looks near enough the same in a photograph, and it sells for less than my leather costs me before I have picked up a knife. You cannot work against that. And there is no villain in it. People just stopped being able to tell the difference, and then they stopped being willing to pay for it.”
That is the actual reason the shop is closing. It is not his hands and it is not his age.
“I’d have done this until somebody carried me out of here. It stopped covering itself about four years ago and I have been running it out of savings since. That is not a business, that is a hobby with a rent bill.”
“The same stuff that emptied this valley is what they sell your piano teacher at Christmas. It sits on a shelf for two years, then it goes in the bin and somebody buys another one. That’s the whole business now.”
And this is what he is still cutting.
Why the last one you owned started peeling at the corner
Ask anyone who plays how many music bags they have thrown out and they will guess low, start counting, then look irritated. Almost all of them fail the same way, in the same place, on the same schedule — and not because they were careless with them.
The shiny ones are faux leather: a thin polyurethane film bonded onto a fabric backing. That film breaks down by hydrolysis . Water works into the polymer, the chains come apart, the coating loses its grip on the cloth underneath and lifts. First it turns tacky. Then a flake comes away on your thumb. Cheap polyurethane is rated at roughly two to three years , the low-grade material at twelve to twenty-four months.
Here is the part nobody puts on the listing: it does not need to get wet. Ambient humidity does it on its own, and it accelerates sharply above about 60% relative humidity.
“It was never you,” Wade says. “It’s the material. It has a shelf life and nobody tells you what it is, because the bag was never meant to be the thing you actually bought.”
Leather has no film to lose. Nothing is bonded to the surface, so nothing can lift off it. It does not peel. It darkens.
What you notice in the first three seconds
The weight, first. Not heavy — it is a shoulder bag — but there is something in your hand, which is not a sentence anyone has ever said about a bag with a keyboard printed on it. That is the hide, not padding. A coated bag gets its body from a foam sheet glued behind the lining, which is also the layer that goes soft and stops holding a shape.
Then the edge. On a coated bag you feel a cut line where the film ends, sometimes sealed with paint that chips. Here it is folded back on itself and burnished by hand, which is why it does not fray.
Then the flap, when you open it. It has a sound. Cheap bags have no sound.
And the smell, which people write about more than anything else and which no photograph carries.
How a leather man ends up making a piano bag
His mother taught him to play in the evenings, on the upright in the front room. Not lessons exactly — she sat beside him and showed him. There was one piece she asked for more than the others, and when he reached the end of it she said the same thing every time, in French, the way her own mother had said it to her.
C’est ma chanson préférée.
That is the line stamped across the keys on the flap. It sits where your hand rests when the bag is closed.
The rest came from something he noticed at the bench and had somehow missed for fifty years.
Piano keys go pale where the hands have been. Leather goes dark where the hands have been. The same thing happening in opposite directions — two objects that keep a record of whoever used them. Almost nothing else a musician is ever given does that at all.
So he made a few. Sold them at markets, a handful a year, mostly to people who play.
What he changed, and why
The first run was wrong — he says this before he says anything good about them. He had used the wrong tannage — it looked excellent new and went grey and papery after two winters, exactly the failure he had spent a working life complaining about in other people’s work. He scrapped the run and started over.
- Cut and finished by one pair of hands. No assembly line.
- A doubled strap anchor. Straps never fail in the middle, they fail at the fixing, where the whole load pivots on two stitches. That is where the second layer of leather goes.
- A flat, stiffened base — it stands up on a bench or a pew instead of folding over the moment you let go.
- A one-handed flap, because the other hand is holding music.
- A firmer patch at the thumb point, the spot on the flap that gets pushed every single time. That is where coated bags crack first. Here it darkens instead.
- A correct octave. Proper spacing, proper groups of two and three across the keys. He plays. He would notice.
- A detachable strap that re-clips to be worn across the body or over both shoulders.
- Two sizes. Large: 13.8 × 9 inches (35 × 23 cm) — takes sheet music. Small: 8.3 × 5.9 inches (21 × 15 cm) — keys, a phone and a pencil.
What it actually holds, honestly
This is the part most listings are vague about. The large one is 13.8 × 9 inches (35 × 23 cm) and takes loose sheet music, laid in sideways. It does not take a ring binder and it does not take a bound method book standing upright — if somebody tells you their bag does, ask them to photograph it. Wade is clear about this because he would rather lose the sale than have it come back.
“A woman ordered one for her teacher and wrote to ask whether an Alfred’s book would stand up in it. It won’t. I told her so, and she bought it anyway, because she’d rather know.”
The small one is 8.3 × 5.9 inches (21 × 15 cm) , and it is not a scaled-down version of the large one. It was cut for a different job — keys, a phone, a pencil, a folded programme — and it is the one that ends up being carried on days that have nothing to do with music.
Then his tannery closed
He had bought his leather from the same building two streets over for most of his working life. It was one of the last still running in the valley, and by the end it employed fewer people than the shop next door to it.
He knew the man who ran it and the man before him. Wade came in on a Thursday, looked at what had come through, took what he liked. No order form, no website — a man at a table who would tell you if a hide was not worth what he was asking.
When the closing was announced he went down on the last morning, mostly to stand there. He came home with the bed of the truck full.
“It wasn’t a business decision. I couldn’t stand watching it go out as scrap, so I put it in the truck, and then I had a problem, which was what to do with a truck full of leather.”
He cut every one of them into bags. It took most of two years.
A hide is not a rectangle. The spine is dense and good, the edges thin and stretchy, and the useful part is smaller than people assume. Wade cuts the flap panels out of the back, where the leather is tightest, and works outward. What is left is offcut, and offcut does not make a bag.
He numbered them as he went, struck into the flap with his father’s steel dies.
There are 398 .
That is not a marketing number, it is a division problem — it is how many bags those hides made. When they are gone there is no second run. Not because he could not find leather somewhere, but because there is no longer a living in cutting it by hand in this country, and the workshop goes when the shelves do.
Why the price is $49
He used to ask $109 at markets and people paid it, because they were standing in front of him and could pick the thing up.
The last 398 have been set at $49 . There is no countdown clock behind that number and nobody talked him into it. There is a finite pile of stock, a trade that no longer pays for itself, and a workshop that empties when the shelves do.
“I’m not going to spend what’s left of this arguing over thirty dollars. I made these so somebody carries one. I’d rather they were on shoulders in Denver and Tampa than stacked in my shop being admired by me.”
From people who already have one
“I’ve taught piano for twenty-six years and I have an entire shelf of piano-shaped objects I have never once used. This is in my hand four days a week.”
“Bought the large one for my daughter’s teacher and the small one for myself, which was not the plan when I opened the page. It smells like a saddle shop.”
“The flap has darkened right where my thumb goes, exactly like he said. Six months in and it looks better than new. My last one was flaking by the second winter.”
The postcard above the bench
Ask Wade what he is proudest of and he does not talk about how one looks coming out of the paper.
“A woman wrote to me in the spring. Bought hers at a market in 2009 — she wanted to know whether I sold spare strap clips, because she’d worn hers through. Seventeen years, and the only thing that gave out was a piece of hardware the size of a thumbnail. I’ll take that.”
“Mr Merrick — mine is seventeen years old. It has been to four states, two funerals and about nine hundred lessons. It looks better than the day I bought it. Thank you for everything you do.”
— Postcard, Burlington, 2026It has been pinned over the bench ever since. It goes in a box when he moves out. Most of that room does not.
It was never the business. It was the hour.
He is careful to separate the two things. The trade was taken from him by arithmetic. The hour was not.
What he did not plan on losing is one particular hour of one particular day, repeated for five decades. The knife goes down around six, the lamp goes off, he drives the six minutes home — and for about an hour nobody wants anything from him and there is nothing left to cut.
“That’s the part,” he says. “Leather all day and the piano at the end of it. Fifty-one years of that, and it never occurred to me the two had anything to do with each other until I was about seventy.”
“People keep asking what I’ll do next. Nothing. I’m not going to sit in a rented unit losing money slower. When the shelves are empty the key goes back and that’s the end of it. There is no 399.”
There is only one place they come from
They are sold through one shop, which his granddaughter Nora, 29, set up after people at the markets kept asking where else they could be found. The honest answer was nowhere, so she fixed it.
“Nora does the computer end of it. I have never once understood any of that. At the minute she is mostly taping boxes shut.”
Worth knowing: look-alikes have turned up on the big marketplaces, and in a photograph they are hard to tell apart. His carry a stamped number on the inside of the flap , struck by hand, and are sold in one place and nowhere else. When these 398 are finished there is no second run — because there will be no workshop left to cut them in.
“Busier than we planned for. A good share of the batch went out this week alone. When they’re finished there aren’t any more — there won’t be a workshop left to make them in.”
— Nora, at the shopWhat it comes down to
It is the one you stop replacing.
Nothing on it can lift off, because nothing was stuck on. It stands up when you set it down. It holds more than it looks like it will. The flap darkens where your thumb goes, and after a few years it stops looking like anybody’s but yours.
And for a while longer it is also this: the difference between the last of it going out on somebody’s shoulder, or sitting in a workshop that is closing either way.
Thank you, Wade.
His guarantee, in his own words
Every one goes out with 30 days, money back, no questions .
“I sold these at markets for years to people who could pick the thing up first. This is the closest I can get to that. If it isn’t for you, put it back in the post and I’ll refund you.”
Claim One at $49 Free US shipping · 30-day returns · cut from the last of his tannery’s hideOne customer sent a photo with hers
“I’ll be honest, I bought this because of the story and half expected to be let down. I wasn’t. It came wrapped in paper with a number struck into the flap, mine is 0231, and a card he’d written by hand.
What actually won me over is stupid and practical. My old bag had to be carried flat or everything slid out of it. This one stands up when I put it down, and the strap comes off so I can wear it on my back in the rain.
The keys on the front are right, which I did not expect and which I checked. And it is bigger inside than it looks in the photographs. That’s the whole review.”
ADVERTISEMENT — This is a paid advertisement. Individual results and experiences vary. Product availability, pricing and delivery times are subject to change.